What is the level of winning papers in academic seminars of library societies in Sichuan, Kyrgyzstan, Jiangsu, Hebei and Guangxi? Provincial level? Equivalent to the municipal level? Or academic level? It depends on how the unit identifies the paper. If there are no relevant regulations, it is estimated that it will not be recognized. Papers evaluating professional titles generally need to be published in regular journals, and it is best to search on HowNet. Nowadays, the periodical market is mixed, and many authors don't know how to identify them at all, and often spend money to be cheated.