First, only half the area is calculated, that is, 1/4 circle area minus triangle area.
=( 1/4)π(4^2)-( 1/2)(4^2)
So the shaded part
=2[( 1/4)π(4^2)-( 1/2)(4^2)]
=( 1/2)π(4^2)-(4^2)
=(π/2- 1)(4^2)
=8π- 16
=9. 12