JOE was the first.
Also known as fat books, fat books. There are many kinds of this book, such as eyebrow approval, side approval, double-line approval and back-and-forth approval, without signature and date. Among them, Zhu Mo's double-row transcription is a major feature of this book. It was not approved nine times. This unique comment on writing is in Chapters 6 and 8.
Fat criticism is far more than other fat copies, especially some important comments he doesn't have. For example, the first poem "Full of Absurd Words" criticized that "only those who can understand can have bitter tears and cry into this book." On New Year's Eve, before the book was finished, Qin died in tears. I tried to cry Qin, but my tears had run out. Every time I look for Green Ridge Peak, I always ask exemptions, why don't I see the monk? Hey! " .
This book was called JOE for the first time because it has a unique sentence "Reading JOE in Zhiyanzhai" and also uses "The Story of Stone". JOE was Qianlong for nineteen years (AD 1754). JOE's first edition is the earliest, so it has always been valued by Redology.
Meng fuben
Meng Fu Ben is the abbreviation of Old Collection of Wang Fu in Qing Dynasty. Because it contains the words "Ye Qi Wang Ye", it is called Wang Mi Ben and Zhi Meng Ben, and it is now in Beijing Library.
Wang Fu consists of 120 chapters, preceded by Cheng Weiyuan's preface and the word "stone". This manuscript has ten kinds of handwriting, which is obviously written by ten people together. The font of the last forty chapters is different from that of the first eighty chapters. According to textual research, Cheng's preface and the last forty chapters were added later, and the original book was eighty chapters. Fifty-seven to sixty-two times is also a supplement.
The writing characteristics of Wang Fu edition are quite similar to those of Bazaar edition and Chen Geng edition, but there are also differences, which are caused by the changes made by later generations. The comment on writing of Zhi Yanzhai in Wangfuben was also sorted out, and some comments of later generations were also included.
Extended data:
Zhiyanzhai
It is said that Zhi Yanzhai is Cao Xueqin's uncle. According to the section of Yin Mourning Xiang Lou, there is a sentence of "life is deleted", which is obviously not the tone of speech of peers and younger generations.
Secondly, it is said that Zhi Yanzhai is Cao Xueqin's second wife, or concubine, because "the clock has struck four times", and Zhi Yanzhai criticized: "Yin wrote it like this, which is taboo", indicating that Zhi Yanzhai is not Cao Shi (the clock struck four times, but Yin Shi) (Cao Xueqin is basically a descendant).
Third, Zhi Yanzhai is Cao Xueqin himself, because no one else can have such a profound understanding of A Dream of Red Mansions except the author himself. Cao Xueqin incarnates as "red inkstone" to prompt and comment on the plot in case others don't understand. This statement has been questioned the most and is not sufficient.
Baidu encyclopedia-lipid review
Baidu encyclopedia-zhiyanzhai